fbpx Skip to main content

Rat in car leads motorist to seek help of JMK Solicitors to resolve disputed claim with Insurer

By 11th June 2020March 4th, 2024Success Stories
Car engine electrical wiring harness damage from rat

Engine damage case study.

JMK Solicitor, Sinead Sinclair acted in a recent case regarding an unusual breach of contract claim against an insurance company.

One morning in late December 2017, the policyholder tried to start his car and a number of engine warning lights came on. Due to the Christmas period, he was unable to get the car to a garage right away. He did not drive the car but the number of warning lights on the dashboard increased and once his repairing garage re-opened in the New Year, he contacted them about the issue.

It was promptly discovered that the damage to the vehicle had been caused by a rat infestation, and the rats had seemingly gnawed at the wires in the engine of the car and caused extensive damage.

Claim declined by insurance company.

The owner submitted a claim to his insurance company but it was declined. This refusal was based on a clause in the contract that excluded damage caused over a “gradual period of time” and it was argued that the damage was gradual since the illumination of the engine lights increased over the time the vehicle was not being driven, and the damage wasn’t as a result of one incident as the allegation was that the rats had done their ‘work’ over many days, so it was excluded under the terms of the contract.

“I can imagine the client humming the tune to an old UB40 song and thinking ‘There’s a Rat in Mi Engine What am a gonna do?’ and lucky for him he was put in touch with JMK by the repairing garage,” Sinead says with a grin. “I instructed both an insurance contract expert and a motor engineer to obtain the relevant expert opinions in support of our client’s case. We then lodged a complaint with the Financial Ombudsman Service regarding the insurance company’s refusal to indemnify the claim for the extensive vehicle repairs which were well over £10,000.00.

Whilst there are no costs risks of losing a case brought to the Ombudsman Service for policyholders it does take a relatively long time for complaints to be adjudicated on compared with Court action.” Sinead stated.

Compensation claim for vehicle repairs.

“After a very lengthy process, a provisional decision was reached which rejected our client’s complaint, however, we mounted further representations to support our contention that the circumstances of the incident fell within the policy terms. We were all extremely delighted that the Ombudsman’s Final Decision was eventually made in our client’s favour, upholding the complaint; and the insurance company was ordered to settle the claim for vehicle repairs in full.

“At JMK Solicitors one of our core values is to achieve the best outcome possible with the resources available, and this includes undertaking the arduous and lengthy process of dealing with both the insurer and the Financial Ombudsman Service in this case,” Sinead concluded.

If you have suffered a personal injury call JMK Solicitors on 028 9032 0222 to arrange a free consultation, or fill in our free enquiry form online; we’ll give you our honest and expert opinion on what we think your claim is worth.

 Every client’s case and set of circumstances are unique and at JMK Solicitors, our personal service ensures we achieve the best outcome for you.


JMK Solicitors are Northern Ireland’s Number 1 Personal Injury Specialists. With a team of over 100 people including a specialist team of personal injury solicitors, we assist clients all over Northern Ireland. If you have suffered a personal injury, been in a road traffic accident, or had an accident at work, contact our team for a free consultation.

Call us today on 028 9032 0222 or email us law@jmksolicitors.com


Translate »